Not tested by us, assessed from specs and documented behaviour
Graph tuning bought as part of a vocal suite, and the catch is the edition: essential moves notes in pitch and time but has no formant tool and no way to reshape vibrato.
How it scored
- Artifact Suppression 8.0
Per-note edits leave deliberate slides alone, which automatic correction cannot.
- Editing Depth 7.0
Melodyne's Main Tool covers pitch, timing and note length, and nothing finer.
- Workflow Speed 7.0
Two tools to learn, the Pitch module for the bulk and Melodyne for the notes.
- CPU Footprint 7.0
Melodyne works from a one-off analysis, and the suite around it is a whole vocal chain.
Why we picked it
Best for anyone who needs note-by-note tuning on a lead vocal and would rather buy one vocal chain than several plugins.
Who should skip it
Avoid if you already own a Melodyne edition or a full vocal chain, because you would be paying twice for the same tools.
The good
- Melodyne 5 essential licence included.
- Automatic and note-by-note in one purchase.
- Most of a vocal chain alongside.
The bad
- No formant or vibrato tools.
- Two tools for the two passes.
- Paying for modules you may skip.
- Modes
- Pitch module and Melodyne 5 essential
- Graph Editing
- Melodyne Main Tool, pitch and timing
- Extras
- EQ, compressor and de-esser modules
- Formats
- AU, AAX, VST3
- Price
- $199
Why it scored that way
The Pitch module handles the automatic pass and the Melodyne 5 essential licence that comes with it handles individual notes. Apart from AutoTune Pro 11, it is the only purchase on this page that covers both.
Nectar 4 Standard is on a tuning page for one reason. iZotope includes a Melodyne 5 essential licence with it, and that is the graph editor this page otherwise lacks outside AutoTune Pro 11. Essential works with Melodyne's Main Tool, which moves each detected note in pitch and in time, changes its length and splits it, and its macros correct pitch and timing across a selection in one pass. In a DAW with ARA support it opens on the track itself rather than asking for the audio to be transferred first.
The suite carries its own Pitch module for automatic correction, with key detection, so the usual division of labour applies. The module takes the bulk of a lead vocal, and Melodyne fixes the handful of notes the automatic pass gets wrong, such as a held note at the end of a phrase that sags flat while the singer runs out of breath. Around those sit two dynamic EQ modules, two compressors and a de-esser, which is most of a vocal chain in one window.
The friction is the edition. Essential has no formant tool, no tool for reshaping vibrato and none of the extended scale functions in the larger Melodyne editions, so a held note with a wide, uneven vibrato can be moved but not tamed. Celemony prices an upgrade at the difference between the two editions' list prices, which is the route to take if the graph turns out to be the part you use most. If the Nectar modules are of no interest, Melodyne 5 essential is also sold on its own, and buying the suite only makes sense when you want the chain as well.